Are tangible rewards or positive reinforcement beneficial tools for improving a child or adolescent’s behavior? The short answer: YES!
However, some parents, guardians, relatives, teachers, community members, etc. at times have difficulty with rewarding kids for several reasons - but to name a few:
Not wanting to reward for acts that the child or adolescent should already be doing.
Not wanting to stifle a child or adolescent’s intrinsic motivation.
Wanting to instill integrity and character in their child or adolescent.
Wanting to limit the cost of rewards.
Wanting the child or adolescent to have the same capacity of performance as adults without a reward being given.
To a certain extent, the above reasons may in part be justifiable to dissuade one from rewarding kids, particularly long-term for the same skill or behavior that has shown progress or has been already mastered. But, generally speaking, these above reasons are also somewhat unrealistic when engaging with children and adolescents. As with anything in life, using rewards as a tool is about being strategic, practical, and flexible. One important goal to remember when rewarding kids is to gradually fade the reinforcement system once the target behavior in question begins to change for the better while shifting gears to focus on a new skill or behavior that needs to be improved.
A novel way to reframe the idea of rewarding a child or adolescent is to consider it a form of compensation akin to a paycheck. Most adults - if not all - would not work for free while taking into consideration other mediating and moderating factors such as motivation, job satisfaction, return on investment, competence, career goal-setting, etc. Apply this same concept to children and adolescents while also factoring in that they are still growing and learning across settings (e.g., home/school/work if applicable/out in the community).
Rewards can also impact and influence a child or adolescent’s reward centers in their brain (akin to a release of dopamine), which is why they can be effective when used appropriately to motivate and reinforce expected behavior.
Rewards (aka: positive reinforcement) can take a variety of forms and do not necessarily have to be expensive in terms of time, money/cost, effort, etc. Rewards can be randomly provided to create a sense of mystery and mastery while also maintaining the child or adolescent’s attention. Rewards can also be discussed in tandem with the child or adolescent to increase their buy-in and motivation to performing the expected behavior (e.g., creating a reward menu of desired items or privileges to pull or choose from with input from the kid).
Check out the additional facts, suggestions and tips also noted below (these are provided as general guidance, but individual differences do exist that need to be accounted for):
Premack Principle (aka: Grandma’s Rule):
This sounds fancier than it actually is - use “First-Then” when directing a child or adolescent (Ex. “First, clean your room. Then, you can have a cookie”).
First-Then can be verbal and/or paired with a visual (Ex. Velcro/laminated individual chart with words and pictures).
Token Economy:
Every time a child or adolescent does an expected behavior, they receive a “token” as acknowledgement (e.g., sticker, checkmark, star, smiley face, etc. on a chart/poster; marble/ticket/bean, etc. in jar; a raffle ticket/Monopoly dollar/fake coin for their bag, etc.).
Once they earn a predetermined amount after a predetermined number of times/days, they are able to exchange their ‘tokens’ for a desired reward (e.g., a toy, a treat, a game, a preferred activity, etc.).
For example: “Johnny, if you earn 4 stickers out of 5 for each school day during the week for following directions, then you can earn a trip to the trampoline park.”
One thing to note: Once the child or adolescent has earned the token, they keep it - avoid taking away tokens already earned to maintain interest and motivation in doing the expected behavior.
Another thing to note: Make the initial goal reasonable for the child or adolescent to master and then gradually increase the expectation - otherwise, their motivation to continue the expected behavior will be stunted before it really begins.
Privileges:
Typically, preferred activities identified by the child or adolescent that can be used as rewards to reinforce expected behaviors.
Privileges can be earned or lost depending on the child or adolescent’s behavior - in other words, consequences can be positive or negative.
For example: “Becky, you can earn a trip to the mall once you have completed your homework.”
Verbal Praise:
This technique should not be underestimated as a reward, particularly when it is used effectively, consistently, and genuinely.
The idea of “Caught you doing good” can be really meaningful and impactful for a child or adolescent; it models for them how to acknowledge others, how to have a positive mindset, how to focus on specific and unique behaviors, and how to be kind and display gratitude to others to new a few impacts.
Think about if a child or adolescent never or rarely hears a positive word directed towards them?!?! Research shows that a ratio of 4:1 for positive-constructive comments can go a long way toward establishing positive relationships between adults and kids across settings (home/school/community).
For example: “Bobby, thank you for helping take out the trash! It helped me finish cleaning the kitchen. Keep it up!”
So, let’s return to the initial question: To reward or not to reward?! There is much greater benefit to rewarding than not, particularly if the ultimate goal is to teach and build a foundation of skills and behavior that will serve the child or adolescent’s social-emotional and behavioral well-being into adulthood.
